Reckoning with Retreat
Reckoning with Retreat
The loss of federal and philanthropic funding is devastating frontline communities and the organizations that serve them. Funders must step into the breach.
By Jacqueline Patterson
Last Friday, a good friend and fierce frontline leader put the payroll for his staff on his personal credit card. The week before, two of the most effective, impactful frontline organizations I know had to lay off half and all their staff members, respectively. Another two organizations have implemented organization-wide pay cuts even as costs for basic needs are skyrocketing.
They are not alone. Recently, I conducted research on the pressures that frontline communities and those who serve them are facing. Though I knew a lot anecdotally, I was shocked at the depth and scale of what I found.
We are living through a cruel structural paradox: frontline racial, environmental, immigrant, labor, and gender-justice organizations are collapsing at the exact moment our communities face an unprecedented, multi-front siege.
The social safety net, never robust, has been shredded. More than 5.8 million people—including over 1.2 million children—have already lost SNAP food assistance. About 10 million more people are projected to lose health coverage by 2034, and $66 billion was slashed from Medicare Savings Programs. Lawfully present refugees, asylees, and domestic violence and trafficking survivors were stripped of federal healthcare eligibility. Immigrant families are traumatized as their beloveds are snatched from the street, or worse, in continuous acts of state sponsored violence.
And, while the administration wages war on DEI, structural racism remains entrenched. Black Americans remain the target of nearly half of all race-based hate crimes. Black mothers die in childbirth three times as often as their white counterparts. Near-record numbers of billion-dollar climate disasters struck in 2023 and 2024, devastating under-resourced frontline communities. The corporations that have long polluted communities of color now do so with impunity: federal civil pollution lawsuits filed by the DOJ on the EPA’s behalf plummeted by 76% in 2025 compared to the first year of the prior administration.
Meanwhile, an aggressive assault on worker power, marked by Executive Order 14251 that strips collective bargaining rights from over one million federal workers, has paralyzed labor protections nationwide.
Just when frontline communities need defense, organizing, and care infrastructure most, our movement is being choked by a three-pronged financial squeeze:
- A Federal Reimbursable Debt Trap: In advance of the Biden Administration’s launch of billions of dollars in funding, philanthropy urged grassroots organizations to become “federal-ready.” Groups climbed every administrative mountain required, securing historic awards under the EPA’s $2 billion Environmental and Climate Justice Community Change Grants and DOJ community violence intervention programs. Because federal cooperative agreements operate strictly on a reimbursable basis, when the administration froze payment portals in early 2025 and ran out the clock past the September 30, 2026, statutory expiration deadline, frontline organizations were left holding six- and seven-figure unpaid liabilities for subgrants, contractors, and payroll already incurred—even after federal courts ruled the terminations unlawful.
- Weaponized Anti-Equity Litigation and McCarthy-Esque Accusations of Terrorism: Coordinated lawsuits under Section 1981 have terrified risk-averse boards and corporate donors into preemptive “mission scrubbing,” stripping race-explicit programs from their portfolios to avoid becoming targets.
- A 90% Philanthropic Retreat: Rather than stepping into the breach, much of institutional philanthropy has retreated. Tracking by Candid and the Philanthropic Initiative for Racial Equity (PRE) reveals that institutional grantmaking explicitly naming racial justice plummeted 90% from its 2020 peak—falling from $926 million to $86.3 million. As of 2023 Black communities received just 1.2% of institutional philanthropic dollars, and rural communities receive less than 7%. As the Center for Effective Philanthropy’s own State of Nonprofits 2026 report documents, 57% of nonprofit leaders say it has become harder to secure foundation grants since January 2025; 44% report reduced funding from existing foundation funders; and the share of nonprofits operating in a budget deficit has nearly doubled, to 39%.
The human fallout is devastating. Between 22,700 and 28,000 nonprofit jobs have been eliminated since early 2025, with one in three nonprofits experiencing government funding losses or stop-work orders, 69% reporting overall funding cuts, 46% warning of closure or forced merger. In California, 84% of organizations serving girls and gender-expansive youth have lost funding. Movement anchors such as Equal Justice USA and the 54-year-old rape crisis center BRAVE Bay Area have shut their doors, while grassroots fiscally sponsored projects silently dissolve without a press release.
Even before these cuts, 35% of Black and 34% of Hispanic nonprofit staff already lived below the ALICE (Asset Limited, Income Constrained, Employed) survival threshold. Now, those workers are being cast out without severance or healthcare to compete for scarce jobs against more than 315,000 displaced federal workers, including 95,371 laid-off Black women civil servants.
“Philanthropy” means the love of humanity. If funders love the people on the frontlines of racial justice, gender justice, democracy, and climate justice, it is time to act. First, funders can enact Immediate Interim First Aid by pooling rapid-response capital to cover worker severance, COBRA healthcare extensions, 1099 cash stipends, and transition fellowships.
Next, funders can commit to 10 Structural Imperatives.
- Double Endowment Payouts: Break past the 5% IRS minimum floor to distribute at least 10% annually over a five-year crisis horizon, following the lead of the Freedom Together Foundation and The California Endowment, to preserve living movements over tax-exempt principal.
- Deploy Balance-Sheet Capital & Absorb Risk: Remove restrictions on active grants, extend “balance-sheet amnesty” to wipe out stranded federal reimbursement debt, and convert CDFI and foundation bridge loans into forgivable grants, as modeled by the John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation, the Kataly Foundation, and The Kresge Foundation.
- Fund Frontline Intermediaries: Channel wholesale capital through trusted, movement-governed hubs (such as The Hive Fund, Mosaic Environmental Fund, NDN Collective, and Frontline Justice Fund) and immediately fund the 1,000+ pre-vetted EPA Thriving Communities applications sitting on the shelf with zero new RFPs.
- Guarantee Multi-Year Unrestricted Support: Commit 3- to 8-year general operating runway with streamlined, oral reporting, following the standard set by Yield Giving and the Ford Foundation’s BUILD program.
- Capitalize Permanent Infrastructure: Endow BIPOC-led anchors and fund shared operational, HR, union-wage, and cybersecurity backbones.
- Resource Convening & Radical Mediation: Underwrite co-strategizing spaces and skilled conflict mediation so organizations can align and build towards systems change.
- End Rural Desertification: Intentionally invest in rural Black, Indigenous, and unincorporated communities long starved of philanthropic capital, where one-third of rural counties have no locally based grantmaking organization at all.
- Sustain Leader Wellness: Fund paid sabbaticals, trauma care, and restorative spaces for frontline Black women and gender-expansive leaders—where severe personal burnout concerns jumped to 46% in 2026.
- Underwrite Legal Solidarity: Fund mutualized legal defense against political intimidation and keep grantees solvent long enough to win breach-of-contract damages in the U.S. Court of Federal Claims.
- Integrate Democracy Power: Resource civic power, state Public Utility Commission interventions, ballot defense, and cooperative economics to defeat corporatocracy.
This month’s midterms reflect what is possible when people move together. Voters cast more than 124 million ballots, a midterm record, and delivered a historic rebuke at the ballot box, with gains reaching deep into states long written off. Frontline organizers knocked those doors and drove those neighbors to the polls; many did it while their own organizations were cutting staff.
Funders should resist reading the results as a sign the storm has passed. An electoral wave can halt a retreat for a season. Only organized movements, resourced year-round, can turn it back. Freedom House has now documented 20 consecutive years of decline in political rights and civil liberties worldwide, and last year the United States tied for the steepest drop of any country rated Free. Two decades of erosion will not be undone on one election night. These gains are a foothold, and communities must widen it by holding power accountable at every level: city council budget hearings, state legislatures fighting over voting rights, and congressional oversight of corporate capture.
That work happens between elections, and it is exactly the work philanthropy tends to abandon. This cycle, more than $11.8 billion went to political ads, the most ever spent in a U.S. election, even though a review of 49 field experiments puts the best estimate of how much campaign ads and contact change voters’ minds in general elections at zero. Then the money goes quiet once the votes are counted, leaving organizers to demobilize just as the fight over governing begins. What lasts is formation: Hahrie Han’s research shows that the groups best at getting and keeping people involved invest in developing their members as leaders, not just turning them out. A return to business as usual would squander this mandate. The power of the people can overcome the corporatocracy when we have the resources to truly get into formation. That means multi-year money for frontline organizers now, while the window is open.
Frontline leaders should not be putting movement survival on personal credit cards while hundreds of billions sit in tax-exempt endowments. Our communities are withering on the vine while those of us working on the frontlines of democracy are fighting with everything we have to keep showing up with them, at the very moment they need it most. This is the moment to step into the breach and fund communities on the frontlines like you love them.